The Eye of the Tiger Shark is a food item introduced in the Shipwrecked DLC. It is dropped by the Tiger Shark and can be used to craft the Super Spyglass. When eaten, it will restore 60 health, and 75 hunger at the cost of 15 sanity. It is considered meat, therefore if left on the ground, nearby Wildbores, Spiders and Snakes will be attracted to it and will eat it.
- The name may be a reference to the song "Eye of the Tiger".
- Food-wise, this item can be considered the Shipwrecked counterpart to the Deerclops Eyeball.
- Quote of Wendy is a reference to a poem by William Blake or possibly to a book Tracy's Tiger where the poem is also present.