Pumpkin Cookies restore the same amount of as Taffy, but do not decrease . This makes Pumpkin Cookies better to eat, while Taffy is slightly cheaper to make. Pumpkin Cookies also spoil faster and restore more than Taffy.
|50% chance to produce Taffy.|
|50% chance to produce Mandrake Soup.|
- Pumpkin Cookies were added in the Insanity! update.